Will Smith waited two decades to release a brand-new album, but the response has surprised many fans. His comeback project, Based on a True Story, featured collaborations with well-known artists like Big Sean and Joyner Lucas, raising expectations that it would make a strong impact. Instead, reports suggest the album struggled to attract listeners.

According to chart data circulating online, the album reportedly generated just 38 digital downloads in the UK during one tracking week and sold fewer than 300 physical copies. While those numbers only reflect the UK market, they quickly sparked conversation across social media about whether the project had failed to connect with audiences.

The album reportedly debuted at No. 62 on the UK Album Downloads Chart before dropping off the following week. It also did not appear on major U.S. charts, including the Billboard 200 or the Top R&B/Hip-Hop Albums chart. Many believe these results show that the album didn’t gain the momentum many expected from a global superstar.

Now fans are debating what caused the disappointing performance. Some believe music tastes have changed since Will Smith’s rap career peaked, while others point to his long break from music or the lasting impact of the Oscars controversy. Others argue the album simply didn’t generate enough interest. What do you think—have fans moved on from Will Smith as a rapper, or did Based on a True Story deserve far more support?